Eleventh Circuit Limits Reach of ADA Accessibility Requirements Online
In a recent decision, the Eleventh Circuit held that Winn-Dixie did not violate the Americans with Disabilities Act by operating a website inaccessible to blind individuals. Gil v. Winn-Dixie Stores, Inc. involved a blind individual who sued the grocery chain after he was unable to refill his prescriptions online or link digital coupons to his rewards card because the Winn-Dixie website was incompatible with his screen-reader software.
The ADA prohibits discrimination on the basis of disability by denying an individual the equal opportunity to enjoy a place of public accommodation’s goods, services, or privileges. The Eleventh Circuit, joining the Third, Sixth, and Ninth Circuits, held that a “place of public accommodation” under the ADA must be a physical place. However, the Court noted that an inaccessible website may still violate the ADA if it serves as an “intangible barrier” to the goods, services, or privileges available at a physical place. In this case, the Court found that the website’s inaccessibility did not serve as a barrier to any of Winn-Dixie’s goods or services because the website was not a point of sale, and all interactions with Winn-Dixie (even those initiated online) required a trip to a physical store to be completed.
A spirited dissent admonished the majority opinion for interpreting the ADA too narrowly. Instead, the dissent argued that the plaintiff received “inferior" treatment from Winn-Dixie because he could not enjoy the privacy or convenience of filling his prescriptions online or linking digital coupons to his rewards card.
The decision comes as a pleasant surprise for businesses in all industries—but especially retailers—harried by the recent wave of “surf-by” suits. However, the case provides only limited protection from future litigation, as the Court’s reasoning depended largely on the fact that Winn-Dixie did not offer any products or services for sale on its website. Brands who do sell products or services online should ensure their websites are accessible to individuals with disabilities.
Vorys can assist in maintaining an accessible website. We can recommend third-party consultants to evaluate a website’s accessibility and educate the brand on maintaining accessibility. Additionally, we can assist in preparing an Accessibility Statement for the website to mitigate the risk of litigation. Finally, Vorys’ eCommerce Litigation and Labor and Employment teams have extensive experience defending companies of all kinds and sizes against ADA website claims and knows how to navigate the potential pitfalls of these matters.
- Marketplace Pulse’s “Marketplaces Year in Review 2019” Emphasizes Amazon’s Growth
- Netflix docuseries Broken highlights prevalence of counterfeit cosmetics products on online marketplaces
- Amazon Creates a Cost-Effective and Efficient Patent Infringement Remedy for Infringing Products Sold on its Marketplace by Third Parties
- U.S. Customs and Border Protection Office of Trade Releases Annual Report on Seizure of Goods Infringing U.S. Intellectual Property Rights
- Vorys eControl Featured in November Issue of Columbus CEO
- Vorys eControl to Host Inaugural eControl360 Summit This Week